Brick vs. Stone Ledger: Which Building Material Delivers More Value?
When choosing a wall finish, builders, architects, and homeowners often compare brick to alternatives like stone ledger or manufactured stone veneer. While all options have visual appeal, only real clay brick has third-party verified sustainability and proven longevity. Here’s how Old Mill’s brick systems outperform the competition.
Performance Comparison
| Category | Clay Brick (EPD Verified) | Stone Ledger / Manufactured Stone | Fiber Cement / Vinyl Panels |
|---|---|---|---|
| Service Life | 150+ years | 40–75 years | 20–40 years |
| Maintenance | Minimal; no sealing needed | Regular sealing every 3–5 years | Repainting or replacement required |
| Environmental Verification | Industry-wide, ISO-certified EPD | Limited or proprietary LCAs | Some EPDs; often higher embodied carbon |
| Embodied Carbon | Moderate; offset by long lifespan | High (cement-based production) | High for cement or petroleum-based claddings |
| VOC Emissions | Zero; inert natural clay | Possible VOCs from binders or resins | Varies; vinyl can off-gas over time |
| Fire Resistance | Noncombustible; NFPA 285 tested | Noncombustible but untested systems | Vinyl is combustible; fiber cement noncombustible |
| Thermal Performance | Strong thermal mass and energy efficiency | Limited thermal benefit | Low insulation; thermal bridging common |
| Recyclability | Reusable or recyclable as aggregate | Difficult to reuse; often landfilled | Rarely recyclable |
| Installation Speed | Fast with Brickwebb; up to 12 bricks per sheet | Slower; requires skilled mason labor | Moderate; varies by panel system |
Why Brick Leads in Long-Term Value
- Proven Sustainability: The Brick EPD is third-party certified, confirming real brick’s environmental performance.
- Long-Term Savings: Brick’s 150-year life means less maintenance, replacement, and waste.
- Fire and Moisture Safety: Old Mill’s Panel+ is NFPA 285 tested and includes moisture drainage channels.
- Energy Efficiency: Panel+ provides continuous insulation—R-4.8 per inch for superior energy savings.
- Authentic Beauty: Real fired clay offers timeless aesthetics without the weight or upkeep of stone veneer.
Conclusion
Brick outperforms imitation materials on every front—durability, safety, environmental impact, and design flexibility. With Old Mill’s Brickwebb and Panel+ systems, you get the authentic look of clay brick backed by verified sustainability and modern installation advantages.
Old Mill Building Products: Real Brick. Real Simple. Real Sustainable.
